Pin-lock
EverChew brand
A SafetyChew nylon locking pin passes through a pre-drilled hole in the bully stick, creating a direct mechanical connection that's secure even with a wet, slippery stick.
Bully Stick Holders: Designs Compared
Bully stick holders grab a chew by squeezing its outside surface. In contrast, EverChew positively secures the chew with a locking pin that passes through a pre-drilled bully stick. This page compares the mechanisms and tradeoffs.
- Locking pin holds to 160+ lb forceUnyielding pin will not let the chew freeWorks even with slobber-slippery chews
- Lock in the chew with just your fingersStop wondering: is it tight enough?Super strong hands not required
- Perfectly fitting refill dog chewsEverChew bully sticks ready to loadOr drill your own sticks with a common drill bit
How the designs differ
Two designs use surface pressure. Only EverChew locks through it.
Screw / Twist Pressure
Twist-screw holders
A plastic or metal screw applies pressure to the side of the bully stick. One product states, "Twist until snug and recheck during supervised chewing". No rechecking with a SafetyChew.
Friction / Grippers
Friction-style holders
Rubber or flexible gripper fingers squeeze around the chew. These are the most difficult to install since the chew must be twisted in.
Scroll horizontally to compare all brands. Keyboard users can focus the table region and use the arrow keys.
| Comparison factor | EverChew (SafetyChew, SafetyChew+, SuperChew) | Bow Wow Buddy | Bully Grip | Woof BullySafe | Chewise | Multi-brand holder (looks like carrot, stick, etc.) | Spot |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| What physically holds the chew? | Pin passes through the bully stick¹ | Friction: Twist-screw pushes against the chew² | Friction: Flexible material grips the exterior² | Friction: Twist-screw pushes against the chew² | Friction: Metal tipped screw pushes chew into metal teeth² | Friction: Twist-screw pushes against the chew³ | Friction: Twist-screw pushes against the chew² |
| How is the chew secured? | Mechanical pin lock¹ | Hand tightened² | Hand tightened² | Hand tightened² | Hand tightened² | Hand tightened³ | Hand tightened² |
| How much of the chew is trapped within holder?How deep is the holding cavity? | 1 inch¹ (but since it's undefeatable, the dog can nibble and pull on the stub⁴ ) | ~2 inches² | ~3/4 inch (small size)² | ~1 7/16 inches² | ~2 inches² | ~1.5 inches (estimated)³ | ~2 inches² |
| Best suited for:⁵ | Owners prioritizing safety and convenience | Owners prioritizing the use of antlers and yak chews | Owners prioritizing holder cost | Owners prioritizing holder cost | Owners prioritizing holder cost | Owners prioritizing holder cost | Owners prioritizing the use of antlers and yak chews |
| Does brand sell refill sticks? | Yes: Low odor, multiple stick thicknesses and lengths¹ | Yes: multiple stick thicknesses and lengths⁶ | No⁶ | Yes: multiple sizes, sold only as an assortment⁶ | No⁶ | No³ | Yes, under a different corporate brand⁶ |
| Sizes for different dogs & chew levels? | Yes: 3 sizes based on dog weight and chew style¹ | Yes: 4 sizes based on dog weight⁶ | Yes: 3 sizes based on chew diameter⁶ | No: 1 size fits most⁶ | Yes: 3 sizes based on dog weight⁶ | No: 1 size fits most³ | Yes: 3 sizes based on dog size⁶ |
| Holder made in USA? | Yes: All materials and components sourced, manufactured, and assembled in US¹ | Yes: about page states "Made in USA"⁶ | Partially: product page states "assembled, and packaged right here in the USA (using globally sourced materials)"⁶ | No: Faire wholesale listing states "Made in: China"⁶ | No: Faire wholesale listing states "Made in: China"⁶ | No: China³ | No: back of product package states "Made in: China"² |
| Primary tradeoff⁵ | Requires a pre-drilled or properly drilled chew | Holder requires strong fingers to grasp twist knob. Potential stick slip risk, especially when wetted by slobber. | Difficult to twist stick into holder. Potential stick slip risk, especially when wetted by slobber. | One size holder--some larger sticks don't fit. Potential stick slip risk, especially when wetted by slobber. | Although recessed, sharp metal components. Potential stick slip risk, especially when wetted by slobber. | Large, clunky holder requires muscles to tighten well. Potential stick slip risk, especially when wetted by slobber. | Red plastic push rod bent slightly as we tightened the holder. Potential stick slip risk, especially when wetted by slobber. |
| Does any stick fit?⁵ | Yes: if you drill the hole it will fit in the small or large models | Yes: if you have the matching size holder | Yes: if you have the matching size holder | No: Larger sticks may not fit | Yes: if you have the matching size holder | Yes | Yes: if you have the matching size holder |
Table data updated November 2026
Sources
1--EverChew self-generated data,
2--Measure/observed in physical sample (owned or in-store),
3--Estimated/observed from amazon listing and images,
4--Since EverChew's holders are undefeatable, we find dogs can nibble on the stub for a long time,
5--EverChew's honest interpretation,
6--Found on company's website (or company's listing on Faire wholesale website).
Which should I choose?
Choose based on the tradeoff that matters most to you.
SafetyChew / SuperChew if your priorities are...
Safety — The locking pin eliminates any guesswork about whether the chew is secure.
Convenience — Lock the stick in with your fingers—no hard twisting, tightening, or rechecking.
Quality Sticks — Use pre-drilled, low-odor EverChew sticks--or drill your own.
Less Waste — Only 1 inch of the chew sits in the holder, leaving more for chewing.
Made in USA — All holder materials and components sourced and built in the US.
A friction-based holder if your priorities are...
Flexibility — Use any bully stick, even stinky ones.
Variety — Secure other chews like yak cheese chews and antlers.
Price — Pay less upfront for the holder.
The tradeoff is intentional
Yes, EverChew uses a hole. Here's why.
The hole is not an accessory to the system. It allows the pin to pass through the bully stick so the stick can never slip out. EverChew's refill bully sticks and collagen chews are perfectly pre-drilled, so they always fit. Some customers drill their own chews, and that's cool too--whatever keeps their dog safe and happy.
Real-world corroboration
What dog owners notice after switching holders.
Real reviews from our real customers.
“It’s nice and small unlike some other holders, and over 5 years and countless sticks, it has never failed once unlike some other holders.”
“I’ve tried a few brands and decided this is the best as my pups can’t choke because of the holder and the sticks are very hearty and each one is the same size!”
“I don’t recommend any other bully stick holders because I want my pups to be safe.”
“I have tried SO many other bully stick holders, and my dogs have always been able to figure out how to get them out, but not with this!”
“We also had mixed results with other holder options… The design is genius, easy to use and has worked flawlessly for us.”
“This is the best and safest bully stick holder I have found. It’s easy for my dog to hold while he chews, and the plastic is a bit softer so it doesn’t become sharp if he chews on the holder.”
Written by Kirby Kendall, EverChew inventor and co-founder. The data and information above is our honest opinion and interpretation. If incorrect, it is accidental and please email Kirby at info@everchew.com so corrections can be made.
Last substantive review: Nov. 2026
Let customers speak for us
The bully sticks are the best
The bully sticks are the best. My puppy loves them. I don’t have to worry about him choking on them. The stand secures the stick so he can’t bite down to a little piece. Need to order more
Karen S.
Best bully stick
My dog loves these.
Melissa W.
Only bully stick holder that really works!
Love your product!! After trying several others that failed I bought you black bully stick holder and bully stick refill pack. Great investment. Jebediah loves the sticks and I love the holder!! Only one I’ve found that actually works. Good job guys🦮
elizabeth m.
What an amazing product
What an amazing product. Takes the scare of the end of the none that you try to keep your pups from swallowing and chocking!!! We order a resupply of bones and additional holder. After our dog finish chewing the bones they chew on the holder!!!
Albert A.
My Cavalier
My Cavalier, Scooter, loves these! Currently he has three in the green holders all lined up on the carpet. He is guarding them!
Dianne W.
Everchew is a great company with safe
Everchew is a great company with safe, great billy sticks and holders! We have two fun loving Goldens who love a treat and they think these bully sticks and holders are the best!
Bill F.
My dog loves these and she even had an irritated
My dog loves these and she even had an irritated gut from a parasite and these where this was the only treat she tolerated!
Anonymous
I love love this, they stay for a long while until they get tired and fall asleep lol, going to order me
Luz
The Best Ever purchase for my dog
I have worked with Anthony whom is very Knowledgeable and supper helpful. this Item is so ingenious. It is the best most well thought out item I have ever purchased. this solves so many issues but my biggest issue is I was wanting the sticks as we would take away the stick before Dora finished them that was a waste. using this item allows the dog to eat all of it except that small nub.
again this is such a great item.
Well done!!!!
Dave Reeves
Dave R.
These are the only bully sticks I will give my dogs
These are the only bully sticks I will give my dogs. I have a 12-pound Chiweenie and a 20-pound Cavalier, and I love the holder, because I don’t have to worry about them swallowing it whole especially the Chiweenie. The quality is excellent and the shipping arrives very quickly. Which my dogs very much appreciate.
Marilee N.
My dog loves this product
My dog loves this product. He gets so excited when he see the bag.
Lamoya S.
These are AMAZING! I never have to worry that
These are AMAZING! I never have to worry that she will choke now!!
pamela d.
Brilliant design that works!
I tried other bully stick holder and my dog, Reggie never used them. This is the first one that has worked for us!! Brilliant the way you designed the holder. The pre drilled holes in the sticks are awesome!
susan g.
My little Goldendoodle can't go a night
My little Goldendoodle can't go a night without her all-natural bully stick She just loves them, and I know it's good for her.
Anonymous
Love
Love them!
Martha S.